100% (1)
page:
10 pages/≈2750 words
Sources:
10
Style:
APA
Subject:
Education
Type:
Article Critique
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 39.6
Topic:

How to help Middle School students from urban areas improve their Reading and Writing scores on Standard Tests?

Article Critique Instructions:
LITERATURE REVIEW: FINAL ASSIGNMENT INSTRUCTIONS Using the approved topic from Discussion: Literature Review – Topic Sentence Assignment, locate and read 10 research articles from academic, peer-reviewed journals (written within the last 5 years). Each article must have middle school/preadolescent children as a major portion of the sample group. Therefore, articles which contain research on students outside of middle school (high school or elementary age) are not permitted . Review articles in their entirety from scholarly, educational sources, such as those from the Association of Middle Level Education, Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development (ASCD), and the professional associations in the various education areas. The following are NOT permitted: editorial journal articles, magazine or non-academic periodicals, newspaper articles, television broadcast transcripts, informational website pages, online educational news service articles, or educational newsletter articles. Write a Literature Review based on the 10 articles (minimum) you have read. Include the following elements (your score will be based on your inclusion of each of the areas delineated):  Organization and presentation of the material related to your chosen topic in a literature review format. Do NOT write this paper as a list of article summaries.  Comparing and contrasting of the articles.  Length of 8–10 pages (not including title page, abstract, or reference page), double- spaced.  The following components must be present and correctly APA formatted: o Title page o Abstract o Introduction – with clear thesis statement o Body  Must follow literature review format with clear comparison and contrast between sources.  Clearly transition between topics. Present your information in an organized and systematic fashion. Demonstrate critical thinking in your review.  Citations within document must follow current APA guidelines for direct quotations and for paraphrases/summaries.  ALL data that is not from your own knowledge bank must be cited and referenced correctly. Failure to do so will result in a 0 for this assignment. o Conclusion that summarizes the Literature Review with suggestions for further study o References  ALL references that are cited in the body must be listed in current APA format.
Article Critique Sample Content Preview:
How To Help Middle School Students from Urban Areas Improve Their Reading and Writing Scores on Standard Tests? Name Institution Course Code and Title Instructor Date Abstract This comprehensive literature review examines research-based strategies to enhance reading and writing proficiency among middle school students in urban areas. Drawing from ten scholarly sources, the review synthesizes findings on the roles of technology integration, classroom management practices, student motivation and self-regulation, targeted writing interventions, critical thinking instruction, and contextual factors influencing urban learners. The research highlights promising approaches such as leveraging educational technology tools, implementing teacher professional development in behavior management, fostering self-efficacy beliefs and adaptive motivational patterns, utilizing intensive writing curricula, adopting discovery-based multimodal learning models, and considering potential rural-urban disparities in motivation. The central thesis is that a multifaceted approach addressing instructional design, classroom environment, psychological factors, and tailored interventions can yield substantial literacy gains for this student population. Areas for future research are identified to guide ongoing efforts in narrowing achievement gaps. Introduction Improving literacy outcomes, particularly in reading comprehension and analytical writing, remains an urgent priority for middle schools serving urban communities. Standardized test data continue to reflect sobering achievement gaps, with students in high-poverty, under-resourced districts performing well below national averages. This literature review examines recent scholarly research investigating interventions, strategies, contextual influences, and psychological factors that may impact the literacy development of middle schoolers in urban settings. The central thesis is that an integrated approach combining effective technology use, robust classroom management, motivational support, evidence-based writing instruction, higher-order thinking skill development, and consideration of sociocultural contexts can yield meaningful progress in this area. Synthesizing insights from ten empirical studies and literature reviews, this paper illuminates a pathway forward for educational researchers, practitioners, and policymakers dedicated to serving urban youth. Technology's Supportive Role in Writing Instruction Research has explored how integrating technology tools into literacy instruction can provide learning platforms, increase engagement, and facilitate skill development. These factors are particularly relevant for urban learners facing resource constraints. In their meta-analysis, Wen and Walters (2022) synthesized findings from 37 prior studies to investigate the overall impact of educational technology on elementary students' writing performance. Their results indicate that technology produced moderate positive effects across ideation, organization, vocabulary usage, and overall writing quality measures. However, the degree of effectiveness varied based on factors like the specific technologies used, student characteristics, implementation approach, and integration models. The authors argue that technology's greatest strengths are in supporting differentiation, scaffolding, increasing engagement and motivation, and facilitating more individualized, student-focused learning. For instance, struggling writers may benefit from using multimedia tools to facilitate brainstorming or receive feedback as they move through the writing process. However, Wen and Walters caution that leaving learners to their own devices will not yield better results from using technology. On the contrary, one requires careful technology integration in a given lesson, with careful implementation and some teacher-led instruction. Liao et al. (2023) came even closer to the comparative case, further illustrating how technology can strengthen engagement and motivation, seen as factors with massive potential to drive literacy achievement. They studied the engagement in an augmented reality game-based language learning app of students in Taiwan's elementary classes from rural and urban districts. The study results showed that students from urban schools had higher motivation and gain in achievement after using the fully immersive AR app compared to those from rural settings. The authors thus suggest that such digital tools, blurring the lines between learning and play, hold considerable potential for boosting youth buy-in among urban youth and others likely to face higher levels of socioeconomic barriers to motivation. However, Liao et al. (2023) also highlighted the persistent "digital divide" in technology access between urban and rural contexts. Indeed, while urban schools often have better technological resources overall, there remain stark disparities within urban districts in the availability and quality of educational tech tools. Equitable access will be vital for technology to serve as an equalizer rather than exacerbating gaps. Overall, these studies reinforce the need for strategic, contextualized technology integration into urban literacy instruction while addressing potential access barriers. Beyond writing, similar benefits of education technology have been documented for reading comprehension and general literacy development. Tools like e-readers, comprehension software, and multimedia platforms can increase engagement, provide individualized support, and create interactive learning experiences. This development is again when implemented purposefully by educators (Herman et al., 2022). As struggling urban readers may face motivational hurdles, strategic technology use holds potential as an intervention. Effective Classroom Management's Outsized Impact A second key area of research centers on the pivotal role effective classroom management practices play in optimizing the learning environment and promoting literacy growth. A study by Herman et al. (2022) used a group randomized trial to examine whether providing behavior management professional development to middle school teachers could translate into improved student achievement. Findings showed that both student groups scored significantly higher in reading and math than in a control group where teachers had not undergone systematic training. The authors indicated that the increase in the amount of high-quality, engaging instruction and decreased disruptive behaviors due to the training developed a more effective classroom environment for learning. The results are consistent with prior research literature that has identified causes such as large class sizes, frequent disruptions, unclear behavioral expectations, and weak classroom management skills as factors that may diminish the quality of academic performance, especially in schools in urban areas. Effective classroom management probably has more benefits than simply increasing instructional time and decreasing chaos. Studies have shown that orderly classroom contexts marked by the regularity of procedures, lack of variation in the enforcement of rules and consequences, the teacher's warmth and trust, psychological safety, and feelings of belonging can help urban students manage the stressors of poverty and community violence. Under these circumstances, students can invest more cognitive resources in learning tasks. Fostering Self-Belief and Adaptive Motivational Patterns A third central line of research attends to motivational beliefs, self-regulation skills, and psychological factors shaping achievement and development trajectories among urban middle schoolers. Several studies have explored how specific mindsets, values, and self-perceptions regarding reading and writing shape academic behaviors, persistence, strategy use, and performance outcomes. Research has consistently spotlighted self-efficacy as a powerful driver of literacy engagement, effort, progress, and skill mastery. Unhealthy perfectionistic tendencies, like perceived parental criticism and socially prescribed perfectionism, are related to a decrease in academic motivation among middle school students in Turkey (Karaman et al., 2020). In their study, higher levels of self-efficacy were significantly predictive of great academic motivation, a predictor of achievement. Wright et al. (2020) adopted another longitudinal design to trace any ch...
Updated on
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

👀 Other Visitors are Viewing These APA Essay Samples:

Sign In
Not register? Register Now!