CR Exercise 3: Bluebeard. Literature & Language Essay
--Need to read the "Bluebeard" story that I upload.
--Must contain 3 quotes from the file that called "Bluebeard" cited in MLA form.
--Must follow the "CR Exercise Rubric" file that I upload
When he talks about "questions of ownership," Donald Haase is expressing concern about the implications or consequences of using fairy tales to instill particular ideologies in specific audiences.
Choose ONE of the Bluebeard tales (except Perrault's "Bluebeard," which we'll discuss in class) to answer the following question:
How does your chosen fairy tale illustrate or complicate one of Donald Haase's arguments about "owning" fairy tales? (Your answer to this question should be the main thesis in your response.)
Start by selecting textual evidence from your chosen tale (as we have been practicing in class). As usual, begin by looking at features of language and style, as well as conventional narrative elements (plot, character, setting, repetition, narrator's commentary, etc.). Then make inferences about:
-The fairy tale's primary message(s)
-The rhetor's purpose in telling the tale in this particular way
-Who the intended audience is, and what their concerns are
-What larger ideologies or contextual forces shape the tale.
Pick 1-2 key passages from the fairy tale that you'll focus your analysis on.
Then, select a passage from Donald Haase’s essay “Yours, Mine, or Ours” to help you develop your answer to the question. Depending on the tale you choose and your own interests, you could focus on one of Haase's criticisms about collective ownership (nationalist, psychoanalytic, or corporate ideology), OR on his positive views about individual ownership.
Remember to quote and analyze relevant evidence from your chosen tale and CONNECT it to one of Haase's ideas.
Think of this CR exercise as a mini-RA. Your goals are to:
Generate an arguable and rhetorically-focused claim about your chosen tale--the more original and complex, the better
-Select, quote, and analyze productive evidence from your primary source (your chosen fairy tale)
-Select, quote, and analyze productive ideas from your secondary source (Haase's essay)
-Organize your ideas in a logical and persuasive order
-Craft clear and sophisticated prose, appropriate for an academic context.
Course
Instructor
Date
CR EXERCISE 3-Bluebeard
Perrault's original “Bluebeard” focuses on the life of a young wife who enters a forbidden room only to discover the husband’s secret, but she drops a key in blood and is later found out, but the bride then planned not to be the next victim. In Brothers Grimm “Fitcher's Bird” one sister helped her two siblings who had been murdered by a sorcerer after she agreed to marry him, and she joined their chopped body parts, where an egg and key made her powerful that the sorcerer listened to her more her murdered sisters. Folktales and fairy tales can be adapted to various contexts and they are powerful as there is individual ownership and flexibility since they appear in to different contexts.
Literary adaptations of the fairy tale captures highlights that they are authoritative when published as is the case with Fitcher's Bird. The Brothers Grimm were interested in retelling the fairy tales and highlighting connections to different cultures in a way that allowed them to own the stories (Joosen 88). For instance, he focuses on a sorcerer with an egg stating “Complementing the classic tales and anthologies with newer or lesser-known stories and variants places the traditional tales in a context that encourages diverse responses” (Haase 397). In introducing new elements in the fairy tale Brother Grimm were successful in taking control and ownership of the folklore in away that represented the idea that folklore inspired different tales. This is consistent with Haase’s idea that ownership over the fairy tales keeps them alive and the power of the tales becomes implicit even today.
Ownership s closely linked with control, and the flexibility of the Bluebeard tales does make them less authoritative. The Grimm brothers (148) reimagining the villain as a man who pretended to be po...