The three perspectives

Essay Instructions:

Assignment Details A 12-year-old boy was caught in the act of battering a 14-year-old female acquaintance by the victim's 16-year-old brother. The brother arrived home, saw his sister on the floor, and observed the 12-year old boy standing over her with his fist raised in the air. The 16-year old brother observed that his sister was not moving. He also saw a shoe with a bloody heel near her on the floor. The victim was almost unconscious when the police arrived. Following the incident, the juvenile was arrested and detained by local police on the following charges: Battery of a minor Aggravated battery with a weapon Minor in possession of an alcoholic beverage Unlawful possession of a controlled substance (marijuana) The juvenile suspect was a latchkey kid (a child who returns from school to an empty home) from a single-parent home. His mother works from 2 p.m.–11 p.m. Monday through Friday, so the juvenile is often alone and unsupervised for several hours upon his return from school. After a preliminary investigation, the juvenile suspect explained that the victim purchased the marijuana and the alcohol earlier that same day. The juvenile explained that the victim had invited him to her house because they had "been liking each other" for a long time. Further, the juvenile explained that the alcohol and drugs were in the home when he arrived. He said that he and the victim began by smoking marijuana and drinking beer before they began kissing and touching one another. Next, according to the juvenile suspect, they started to have what he described as consensual sex. After a short while, they were interrupted by the victim's brother, who had come home from work. The victim’s brother then called the police to report the incident. The juvenile had prior detentions for violation of curfew, truancy, and attempted sexual battery. No further explanations are given. Write an essay of 750–800 words, divided into 3 sections: The perspective of the police officer What typically happens to this juvenile before he goes to juvenile court? How does law enforcement process the incident? The perspective of the state's attorney If you were the state's attorney, what would you suggest to the court regarding how the boy should be punished, sentenced, rehabilitated, or any combination of these options? The perspective of the judge Based on the facts of the case and the procedures of the juvenile justice system, what would be the most appropriate finding of the court? What options does the judge have in this incident? Make sure that your essay addresses the following: Do each of these components of the criminal justice system see the offender as a status offender for any of the charges? Discuss your opinion of the status offender from the perspective of each criminal justice component (law enforcement, state's attorney, and the judge). Are the charges viewed by each of the criminal justice components listed below as delinquent acts? Be sure to cite all references in APA format. You will be marked down if you use any adult court terminology in your paper! Juvenile court has its own definitions and procedures.

Essay Sample Content Preview:

Juvenile Case Analysis- The Three Perspectives Name Institution Course Instructor Date Juvenile Case Analysis- The Three Perspectives The case presented is that of a 12-year-old boy associated with several charges against a 16-year-old female, which drives multiple questions about the juvenile system of justice. This paper explores the case in three main dimensions, focusing on the perspectives of stakeholders, such as police law enforcers, the state's Attorney, and the judge, regarding the handling of this case. It further discusses the concept of status offenders, the possible charges, and the courses of action. The Perspective of the Police Officer Every state has its laws that govern the arrest procedures for juveniles. Generally, law enforcement officers should follow a legal process when a juvenile is subject to arrest after violating the law (Sari, 2020). First, the minor is temporarily detained until a parent or guardian arrives at the scene. More often, the juvenile is then given a warning and released (Papadopoulos, 2023). Although the officer is not required to release a minor in the custody of their parent or guardian, they often do so. Secondly, the minor is only arrested if a police officer recognizes them as a repeat offender or the case appears more serious and taken to the police station upon arrest (Stolzenberg et al., 2021). The officer plans for the detention of the minor in a juvenile facility while at the police station or releases them into protective custody, such as the care of a social worker or other child protective services, or the juvenile is released into the custody of the parents. Upon placement of a juvenile in juvenile detention by the officer, the case is then referred to the juvenile court system, where a prosecutor or a juvenile court officer takes responsibility for the minor's case. In the juvenile court, the prosecutor or the juvenile court officer decides whether to drop the charges, informally solve the allegations, or file a formal charge referred to as a delinquency petition. The decision by the prosecutor or the juvenile court officer on whether to bring charges depends on several factors, such as the age of the minor, the severity of the charges, the presence of prior juvenile records, the nature, the strength of the available evidence against the juvenile, and the perceived ability of the parents to manage the child’s behavior (Zane et al., 2022). In the case study, the police arrest the juvenile suspect based on charges such as battery, alcohol possession, aggravated battery with a weapon, and possession of marijuana unlawfully. The police, therefore, perform a thorough assessment and investigation through witnesses to gather evidence. The victim’s condition, explanation by the suspect, and previous history are considered. The officer assesses whether this case should proceed to the juvenile court or if alternative measures are more appropriate. The Perspective of the State's Attorney A state's Attorney is capable of helping a minor to go for rehabilitation instead of the punishment decided by the juvenile court (Carter, 2020). Being the state's attorney general in the above case, I would recommend three options for the suspect. Consi...

Updated on July 12, 2024

Get the Whole Paper!

Not exactly what you need?

Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

Order