Ethical Issues at Tim Hortons and Potential Challenges

Ethical Issues at Tim Hortons
Student Name
Institution
Course Name
Instructor
Date
Ethical Issues at Tim Hortons
Tim Hortons Inc., a Canadian food service chain, has recently encountered several ethical problems. These issues have caused its stakeholders to express fears about confidentiality, transparency, and ethical business methods. The ethical challenges Tim Hortons faces also relate to the ethical procurement of their coffee beans. Tim Hortons received further criticism for how it dealt with its franchisees; some claimed they were made to sign unjust contracts and endure harsh demands. The business faced criticism in 2017 when it eliminated a paid break for its workers. Tim Hortons has also come under fire for its record regarding the environment, with some claiming that the firm is to blame for deforestation and the effects of global warming. Fast-food businesses frequently come under criticism for the nutrient content of their products. Animal welfare issues have been brought up concerning where Tim Hortons gets its ingredients. Tim Hortons must address these ethical issues to preserve its brand and meet the demands of customers who value social responsibility.
Literature
In 2019, the Tim Hortons mobile app was discovered to be recording the exact location of its customers even when the mobile application was not being used. Because the customers' movements were being tracked without their prior approval, this generated serious privacy issues. According to Canada's privacy authority, Tim Hortons utilized the mobile application to gather enormous quantities of location data from customers, including information about when they frequented rival cafes. The coffee shop was the subject of a 2020 probe by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (2022), which demanded that it remove any location data still in existence and restrict future data collection. Although Tim Hortons stated that the monitoring was done to enhance the customer experience and provide targeted advertising, the lack of openness and oversight over collecting data about clients raised ethical concerns. Regaining customer trust required Tim Hortons to solve privacy issues and improve disclosure about data gathering procedures.
Tim Hortons' top ethical concerns are equal compensation and employee rights. Various claims have been made about low pay, insufficient benefits, and unfavorable working conditions for personnel. These problems have spurred protests and requests for better labor laws, highlighting the necessity of fair pay and a greater appreciation of employees. Tim Hortons encountered criticism from the public in 2018 after some franchisees slashed paid breaks and benefits for workers in reaction to a raise in the minimum wage in Ontario, Canada. Tim Hortons restaurants in Cobourg, Ontario, and some outlets across the region implemented debatable cost reductions in response to the Ontario $ 14.00-an-hour hike in January 2018 (Durrani, 2021). Personnel at a Cobourg Tim Hortons restaurant owned by the proprietor's children have been requested to agree to an updated contract detailing several changes that will significantly alter their terms and conditions of employment. Such changes include a significant reduction in staff benefits and the elimination of paid breaks. Personnel who have worked at the location for more than five years must pay 50% of their perk costs, while those who have worked there for more than six months must pay 75% of their perk costs (Durrani, 2021). Personnel with more than five years of experience were previously fully protected. This action was viewed as unethical because it made workers responsible for higher labor costs rather than deducting them as business costs. Tim Hortons faced difficulty addressing the bad impression these franchisees' conduct had given of the company and proving its dedication to treating employees fairly across the board.
For its sustainability initiatives and environmental policies, Tim Hortons has drawn criticism. The corporation's adoption of non-recyclable and non-compostable containers, high water usage, and lack of openness in acknowledging its adverse environmental effects have all drawn criticism. Tim Horton's coffee may be manufactured ethically in the eyes of certain individuals, whereas the company's ecological and social policies might cause concern for others. The fact that Tim Hortons is accredited by Fair-trade Canada, the Rainforest Alliance and has promised to source only sustainable coffee beans are a few of the key justifications for the business's ethical coffee (Hutchinson et al., 2021). However, certain stakeholders could continue worrying about the business's general impact on the environment and employment policies. Tim Hortons' refusal to tackle these issues can be perceived as an ethical failure at a time when people are becoming more environmentally sensitive. Plastic covers, wrapping, and single-use cups are frequently used, which increases garbage and pollution. Although the coffee shop has taken measures to provide recycling incentives and programs for reusable cups, the total impact is still a cause for concern. The coffee chain faces difficulties examining and implementing environmentally friendly methods across its business, such as boosting the usage of recyclable or compostable items and lowering waste production overall.
The origin of Tim Hortons' coffee beans is yet another ethical dilemma. Questions have concerned the firm's dedication to fair trade principles and ensuring that coffee producers are fairly compensated for their labor. The fast-food chain buys its coffee from nations including Guatemala, Honduras, and Nicaragua, where laborers get compensated as little as $2 per day, according to a CBC study (Harris, 2018). Employees must put in as much as sixteen hours a day in certain instances. Besides, producers that employ child labor frequently supply Tim Hortons with its coffee. A recent Human Rights Watch research revealed that minors under 12 worked on coffee plantatio...