Issues in Nursing: Shortages of Nurses
Assignment 1
Purpose
The purpose of this assignment is to
• develop skills in analyzing media-presented issues related to the nursing profession and nursing practice; and
• explore the public perception of nurses and the nursing profession.
To complete this assignment:
• focus on a current issue in nursing; and
• examine this issue in the context of written opinions expressed through three (3) separate types of media.
Issues are often value laden; issues in health care and in nursing are no different. Concerns about the state of our health care system and the state of nursing in Canada have been discussed at length within the media, government, and nursing organizations. While it is often difficult to differentiate fact from fiction and opinion, public opinion is often influenced by what is written in the popular press or on the Internet.
Assignment Expectations
• Find three articles on the same issue/topic.
o One of the articles must be from a popular periodical or media source, preferably something you may have at home (such as Macleans, Time, Reader's Digest, or your local newspaper – either print based or online version) or CBC, CTV, GlobalTV, or online articles.
o Your second article must be from a scholarly periodical retrieved from a database [e.g. AU Library, CINAHL, Medline, etc.].
o The third article must be from a Web site that is not merely a Web version of a print source (e.g. blog, podcast, e-newsletter).
o The articles should represent a range of views. In other words, these articles should not all agree.
• The introduction includes a thesis that prepares your reader for the general topic the articles address, the issues they raise, and the position you will be taking.
• Summarize each article separately by stating in your own words the important information presented in each article and any arguments the authors make.
o Do not paraphrase the whole article; present the main points briefly—each summary should be one paragraph long, two at the most.
o When summarizing, it is not appropriate to dwell on extended examples (such as personal case histories or stories); you do not need to summarize complex statistical parts of a study.
o You should focus on the main ideas and issues discussed. You could briefly refer to any specific personal stories or statistical sections of the piece (using one or two sentences).
• Respond to the three articles by:
o comparing the authors’ credibility, documentation, and support for claims;
o evaluating any disagreements or agreements between the authors; and
o articulating your own position on their ideas or issues. This means more than just stating your opinion; you must also explain it.
• Describe how your personal and professional values influence your views on this issue.
• Document your sources using correct APA style. This paper adheres to a 5 page limit excluding tireference and title pages.
Resources: class textbook:
McDonald, C., & McIntyre, M. (2019). Realities of Canadian nursing: Professional, practice, and power issues (5th ed.). Wolters Kluwer Health.
Paper title: Shortages of Nurses
1. Article #1 from Time magazine – Contract Nurse Agencies Are Making Big Money in the Age of COVID-19. Are They 'Exploiting' the Pandemic?
https://time(dot)com/6149467/congress-travel-nurse-pay/
2. Article # 2 – Nursing Shortage
https://www(dot)ncbi(dot)nlm(dot)nih(dot)gov/books/NBK493175/
3. Article # 3 - There Is No ‘Nursing Shortage.’ There’s Just a Good Nursing Job Shortage
https://www(dot)thenation(dot)com/article/archive/health-care-medicare-nurses/
References
Chen, M. (2019). There is no ‘Nursing shortage.’ there’s just a good nursing job shortage. The Nation. https://www(dot)thenation(dot)com/article/archive/health-care-medicare-nurses/
Haddad, L., Annamaraju, P., & Toney-Butler, T. (2022). Nursing shortage - StatPearls - NCBI bookshelf. National Center for Biotechnology Information. https://www(dot)ncbi(dot)nlm(dot)nih(dot)gov/books/NBK493175/
Hospitals say nursing agencies are 'Exploiting' the pandemic. (2022). Time. https://time(dot)com/6149467/congress-travel-nurse-pay/
McDonald, C., & McIntyre, M. (2019). Realities of Canadian nursing: Professional, practice, and power issues (5th ed.). Wolters Kluwer Health.
Shortage of Nurses
Student’s Name
Institution
Course Number and Name
Instructor’s Name
Date
Shortage of Nurses
One of the major problems facing many healthcare systems around the world is the shortage of nurses. The challenge became severe during the COVID-19 pandemic when the resources of many hospitals were overwhelmed. The shortage of nurses directly affects patient outcomes and without sufficient plans to address the problem, the healthcare sector could plunge into a crisis. It is apparent that healthcare organizations are primarily concerned about profits while neglecting the interests of key stakeholders including nurses and patients. The nursing shortage problem has been addressed in many media articles, some of which are scholarly while some are targeted at a wider audience. This paper analyzes three articles that have focused on the nursing shortage. The nursing shortage is a complex problem that is mainly driven by the healthcare organizations’ focus on profits at the expense of the affairs of nurses.
Summary of Articles
Article #1: Vesoulis and Abrams (2022)
Published in Time Magazine, the article by Vesoulis and Abrams (2022) explore how contract nurse agencies are reaping huge profits amid the healthcare sector experiencing shortages. While historically nurses have experienced heavy workloads, the COVID-19 pandemic made it worse not only due to workload but also as a result of the health risk of working in hospitals. In the last two years, many nurses quit their jobs to join contract travel nurses who are paid two to four times more. Interestingly, hospitals in turn have to hire contract nurses to fill the gap, creating a vicious cycle. With the contract agencies charging exorbitant rates for their services, hospitals are facing a crisis. The large increase in contract nurses has elevated the staffing budgets for hospitals, which has forced them to call for interventions from the government to investigate the exploitation by contract agencies. With 21% of nurses planning to leave work within six months, the healthcare system could crumble. A key idea from the article is that the poor working environment is main the reason for the shortage.
Article #2: Haddad et al. (2022)
In this article, the authors highlight the key issues surrounding the nursing shortage. With nurses and midwives totaling about 29 million in number globally, they are an important part of the healthcare system. Job openings for nurses are bound to increase faster than any other occupation in the next few years. The aging population and workforce, career and family issues, burnout, and violence at work are some of the main drivers of the nursing shortage. While the aging population means a higher need for healthcare services, the aging workforce means more nurses are retiring or are bound to retire in the next few years. Given that nurses are primarily female, they often leave work to give birth or take care of family. Burnout and violence in the workplace characterizes the stressful work environment of nurses, prompting many to leave. As nurses quit work, the patient-to-nurse ratios increase, leading to more errors and increased mortality rates. Technology solutions such as Electronic Medical Records (EMR) elevate the shortage problem by taking away nurses from direct care. Empowering nurses by making the workplace conducive can help address the high turnover rate.
Article #3: Chen (2019)
In her article, Chen expounds on how the problem of nursing shortage is more about the shortage of good nursing jobs than actually a shortage of nurses. Nurses are burdened by heavy workloads as they have to work marathon half-day shifts while handling too many patients. According to nurses, the notion of a shortage does not tell the complete picture as factors such as high patient loads, hospital budget cuts, and a focus on profits by hospitals contribute to the problem. The shortage is viewed by labor advocates as artificial because hospitals are preferring to hire less-qualified and less-paid personnel in place of registered nurses. Due to stress, nurses, some of who are just at the start of their careers, have resorted to leaving the profession. Mandates that specify the staffing ratios are key to addressing the issues faced by nurses as well as improving patient outcomes. The author advocates for single-payer insurance, which will ensure staffing levels are sustainable.
Response to Articles
The authors of the articles possess the relevant experience to write informative and relevant articles on the challenge of nursing shortage. The first article was authored by Abby Vesoulis and Abigail Abrams, both of whom are reporters at Time Ma...
👀 Other Visitors are Viewing These APA Essay Samples:
-
Health Education: Impacts on Knowledge of Healthcare Waste Management
3 pages/≈825 words | 2 Sources | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Research Paper |
-
Preventing Diabetic Foot Ulcerations
4 pages/≈1100 words | 3 Sources | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Research Paper |
-
How Effective is Daily Foot Care Compared to No Daily Foot Care
4 pages/≈1100 words | 3 Sources | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Research Paper |