100% (1)
Pages:
6 pages/≈1650 words
Sources:
7
Style:
Turabian
Subject:
Social Sciences
Type:
Essay
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 29.16
Topic:

Perfect Union: Christian Worldview With The Idea Of World Government

Essay Instructions:

You will craft individual essays in response to the provided prompts. You must use current Turabian style with default margins and 12-pt Times New Roman font. For each essay, include a title page and reference page, also in current Turabian format. You must include citations to a sufficient number of appropriate scholarly sources to fully support your assertions and conclusions (which will likely require more than the minimum number of citations). Each paper must contain at least 5-7 scholarly sources original to this paper, not including the course textbooks, presentations, or Bible.



Essay The UN— “A More Perfect Union?”

Considering the readings, video presentations, and your own research, draft a quality 5–7-page research paper on the role, legitimacy, and authority of the UN according to the following prompts, answering in a separate or integrated manner as you wish:

What is the relationship of the UN to the current international system of states? Considering the reasons for the creation of the UN after World War 2, does it seem driven by political necessity or political utility? In plainer English, do states need the UN more than the UN needs the states? Or do states both large and small find the UN a useful tool for improving their relative power and legitimacy vis-à-vis other states and global institutions? Is there some position in-between?



Identify at least 3 reasons that states might defend the intrinsic legitimacy of the UN as a governing authority. In reverse, identify at least 3 reasons that states might criticize its legitimacy and authority. In short, make an argument for the limits and possibilities of the UN as a legitimate governing authority in a world of sovereign states.



Using biblical and extra-biblical sources (The Bible, commentaries, teachings, other writings, etc.) to inform your own reasoning, comment on the compatibility of a Christian Worldview with the idea of World Government. [Attention: The Instructor does not view the question as rhetorical, nor the answer self-evident. So, reason carefully.] For example, if the logic of collective action under the Articles of Confederation—the logic of state sovereignty—failed to secure American liberties as well as the ‘more perfect union’, the new Constitution established by the Framers in 1787 to replace it, effectively requiring states to cede sovereignty to a larger collective authority, why would the same logic of collective action not justify the UN as a ‘more perfect union’ to replace



https://www(dot)youtube(dot)com/watch?v=tlmYtJiUK00

https://www(dot)youtube(dot)com/watch?v=5RR4VXNX3jA

https://www(dot)youtube(dot)com/watch?v=ifGxnlu94hQ

https://www(dot)youtube(dot)com/watch?v=Qa9j1lhs2iU

https://www(dot)youtube(dot)com/watch?v=0ViSYjt-wGw

https://www(dot)youtube(dot)com/watch?v=1dqFredlTeE

Essay Sample Content Preview:

The UN- “a more perfect union?”
Name
Course
Instructor
Date
Introduction
Global governance is the system formed by the set of rules, processes and actors, institutional and others, that govern the world more specifically, which intervene or are part of the decision making taking place at the global level. The scope of global governance now extends beyond security and conflict resolution, to other issues of international relations, including issues such as economic production, development, finance as well as climate change, pollution, energy governance and resources, and the arms industry, which influences conflicts. The global governance players mostly include the global institutions such as the UN, regional institutions, nation-states, global civil-society groups and multinationals, which are influential in the political sphere. The UN has legitimacy among member estates, but veto powers, infringing on political sovereignty of member states and failing to protect rights for all people are associated with opposition to the organization.[Margaret P Karns, Karen A Mingst and Kendall W Stiles, International Organizations, 3rd ed.(Boulder, Colorado: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 2015), 75.]
States and the UN
The Charter of the United Nations is the foundational treaty of the UN created in 1945 just after WWII and UN member nations that recognize its jurisdiction and countries need the UN and mostly represent the UN treaties. The United Nations' General Assembly adopts resolution and agendas on different issues, and while countries are expected to comply they do not always do so. For instance, the US is not a party to the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court (ICC), and based on disagreements about the country’s complicity in human rights abuses in foreign affairs matters. The powerful countries major powers have veto power based on the balance of power during the 1940s and can drive agenda using the support of allies to influence agenda, but even when they disagree they are still members of the UN.
Global governance is based on the premise that governance depends on individuals, public and private institutions public that work together to manage common affairs. There was growing interest in global governance to support relations between states after the Cold War, and prior to this global governance mostly occurred without institutions. Even though, there may be conflicting or divergent interests there is cooperation among actors and monitoring compliance, while there are arrangements to cater to the interests of different actors. This is important as strong nations are less likely to coerce their weaker counterparts by virtue of projecting political, economical and military power.
Legitimacy of the UN as a governing authority
While the UN is imperfect member states often support the agency and there is a link between international governance and development cooperation. The UN has supported democratic governance and sustainable governance by recognizing the rights of the people. Member states also adopt resolutions that help to guarantee political rights and with increased international commitment when the body is considered relevant. There is more equitable participation in decision-making among the developing countries, and the UN facilitates cooperation for development by prioritizing issues that need to be addressed at the global level. Furthermore, countries are committed to multilateralism and this shows good faith in cooperating with the UN the main forum that facilitates this.[Jonas Tallberg and Michael Zürn. "The legitimacy and legitimation of international organizations: Introduction and framework." (2019), 2]
The Security Council is the strongest arm of the UN and while there are only 15 members help to maintain peace and authorize military interventions and UN peace keepers. The UN Security Council plays an important role in maintaining international peace and security on behalf of the member states. Since the UN promotes cooperation among all nations the agency helps to reduce the risk of future conflicts and supporting the protection of fundamental rights in different countries. States choose to join the forum as it is beneficial and there is mutual cooperation, which is necessary to maintain international peace.[Karns, Mingst and Stiles, 123.]
When there is adequate representation at UN forums, the meetings help to facilitate international negotiation. The representatives of the member states negotiate and may even seek intervention from the UN. Nonetheless, the success of the UN partly depends on compliance by the great powers. Political intervention has been supported in cases where there are various warring parties and helped to maintain peace in cases where negotiations are difficult. Where possible the UN supports good governance and integrity, which helps to facilitate negotiation.[Devika Hovell. "Due process in the United Nations." American Journal of International Law 110, no. 1 (2016), 21]
Countries pursue their national interest and membership to the international organization is voluntary while members do not always abide by resolutions. The permanent members of the Security Council have used their veto power to support and undermine certain resolutions, and especially the US and Russia. Each state has its own interests at the global stage and allies that support many of their positions. For instance the US is Israel’s strongest ally and has shot down resolutions on the Israel- Palestine conflicts. President Bush also invaded Iraq without authorization from the UN during the War on Terror era.
International institutions such as the UN are not always considered legitimate and as such are incapable of becoming agents of change. In the UN and its agencies, decisions are made and that affect millions of people who did not elect the representatives of these institutions. In spite of everything that the UN has done, the agency has failed to solve ...
Updated on
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:
Sign In
Not register? Register Now!