100% (1)
Pages:
7 pages/≈1925 words
Sources:
3
Style:
MLA
Subject:
History
Type:
Essay
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 25.2
Topic:

Examine how race continues to shape contemporary life in Brazil

Essay Instructions:
The essay should cite actual evidence from the texts in question as citations and should analyze that evidence by paying careful attention to the actual words used and their implications. Strong essays will give careful consideration of the actual language used in their sources and will develop their discussions according to an analysis of ideas as reflected in these sources. "Race" in Brazil has had very different implications throughout its history. The attempted enslavement and decimation of Amerindians in addition to the enslavement and forced migration of Africans, while economically motivated, are premised upon ideas about race and ethnicity. The continuing legacy of these events in Brazil provide, as well, opportunities to examine how race continues to shape contemporary life in Brazil despite the relative remoteness of the colonial period. Return to Manoel de Nóbrega's "Letter to Governor Tomé de Sousa," Pêro Vaz de Caminha's "Letter," Jean de Léry's History or to Sweet's history of the life of Domingos Álvares, and find examples or specific evidence that you can then read in the light of Edward Telles' ideas regarding race and color in contemporary Brazil. Be sure to call upon, as well, some of the other texts read in class to enrich and contextualize your discussion. Finally, it is essential that you call upon specific examples from each text and that you analyze and address the specific language that is used. In this regard, please avoid mentioning current or historical events beyond the bounds of the course. Also, avoid making references to "human nature" or the "human condition" or any other similarly imprecise ideas. Alternatively, call upon concrete examples from the texts that we have read, and analyze them according to some of the models that we discussed in our last class or others that you find relevant. I have attached the required readings.
Essay Sample Content Preview:
Name: Instructor: Course: Date: The Enduring Legacy of Racial Ideologies in Brazil Race in Brazil has been central to the formation of social, economic, and cultural life from the beginning of history until now. Since early colonialism, it was driven by financial reasons that are embedded deeply in conceptions about race and ethnicity: successive attempts at enslavement and the consequent decimation of Amerindian populations, forced migration, and eventual enslavement of Africans. These events led to the creation of a complex racial order that still pervades Brazilian society today. The paper explores how valid historical perspectives are in defining Brazil's modern racial landscape by analyzing primary material such as Jean de Léry's "History of a Voyage to the Land of Brazil" and Manoel da Nóbrega's "Letter to Governor Tomé de Sousa" in addition to Edward Telles's insight in "Race in Another America: The Significance of Skin Color in Brazil.". Jean de Léry's Observations The historical context of race in early Brazil is powerfully connected to the European explorations and colonizations during the 16th century. Jean de Léry, in his "History of a Voyage to the Land of Brazil," vividly captures these early times and the racial eddies that come into play. At this time, what makes Léry's observations so important is the fact that they are one of the significant depictions of how Europeans regarded race and ethnicity. One of Léry's strengths, and what he does best, is detailing the Tupinamba people and the Brazilian environment. He goes on: "For his vivid and subtle ethnography of the Tupinamba Indians and his minute description of the marvelous abundance of their natural setting provide one of the most detailed and engaging of the reports we have of how the New World looked while it was indeed still new" (Lery xv). This careful description does not just highlight the novelty of the New World in European eyes but also portrays, in general, how European attitudes towards Indigenous people were those of studied creatures without the possibility of regarding them as equals. The language Léry employs bears heavy implications regarding race and ethnicity. The idea of Tupinamba being "savages" is starkly opposite to what he had started with—his meditations on comparing what is different and what is similar between the Europeans and the indigenous people. Léry uses this word in numerous ways to indicate primitiveness and otherness; it is pretty apparent, with his inherent biased perspective and ethnocentric view, how it would have shaped the European actions toward him. The language subtly validated the necessity of colonizers, who were seen as superior, and their actions in this New World. Moreover, Léry's account of the Tupinamba is a window into early concepts of race. For instance, he notes, "The experience of that period, together with those of previous extensive excursions while they were still with Villegagnon's colony, provided the material for Léry's ethnography" (Lery xxi). That passage suggests that direct experience and observation were paramount to the early ethnographic record, many of which, by very nature, were infused with both genuine curiosity and deep-seated prejudices. The point of this entire episode from Léry is the interactivity that existed between the Europeans and the indigenous people, where both cooperation and conflict were a fundamental dynamic. For example, the extended period of mutual dependency between Léry and his companions and the Tupinamba ordeals is reflected in these early interactions. He acknowledges the importance of the assistance of the Tupinamba, but at the same time, his narrative reinforces their otherness. Manoel da Nóbrega's Paternalistic View Early race relations in Brazil are thus nestled within the historical background between the white-dominant European colonizers and the native Amerindian tribes. In "Letter to Governor Tomé de Sousa" by Manoel de Nóbrega, the Jesuit friar is deeply grieved by what he perceives as a moral decay of the colony and expresses desires for the reformation of Christians and the conversion of Amerindians. He writes, "Since I have been in this land, to which I came with Your Majesty, two desires will torment me always… " (Nobrega 36). Nóbrega reveals from his very language the old ideas that go with race and ethnicity, underlined by a very paternalistic view of the Amerindians—that they are "heathens" who must be "subjugated and thrown under the yoke of obedience to the Christians" into proper conversion (Nobrega 38). Such words suggest a belief in the natural superiority of the Europeans and, hence, the necessity of handling and directing the other population for their sake, which is supposedly better. It will, in turn, support the colonial idea that insisted on the inferiority of non-Europeans as well as a desperate need for European civilization. Nóbrega's comparison with Amerindians in Peru and the Antilles saying "the heathen is of a nature that, once subdued, the faith of Christ will be written very well in his understandings and desires" reinforces this standard colonial mindset (Nobrega 38). The examples from this letter by Nóbrega represent early colonial ideas toward race, in which differences were a justification to subjugate and convert. The impression of such attempts was that Amerindians needed to be isolated in villages run by Jesuits so as not to get morally corrupted and for ...
Updated on
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:
Sign In
Not register? Register Now!