Planning study analysis assignment

Equitable Urban Development: A Critical Analysis of the 1910 Eglinton Ave E Project through the Lens of the Golden Mile Secondary Plan Student Name Institution Professor Name Course Date Equitable Urban Development: A Critical Analysis of the 1910 Eglinton Ave E Project through the Lens of the Golden Mile Secondary Plan This paper considers the development application for 1910 Eglinton Ave E, primarily how it responds to the urban planning principles and the equity issues raised by the Golden Mile Secondary Plan context. The relevance of the application is attributed to its influence on the local development patterns, community service, and overall urban fabric, hence the need for justice in planning decisions (Sandercock, 1998). The Google Street View of the present location at 1910 Eglinton Ave E shows the modern commercial buildings in an entirely urban environment. Commercial, service, and residential units are found in this mixed-use zoning district. The envisaged project suggests converting the site into a mixed-use facility comprising housing, retail, and public amenities. This transition requires zoning adjustments to cater to the growing density, elevation, and range of land uses, conforming to more sweeping urban renewal goals. The Golden Mile Secondary Plan, a context plan for the area, focuses on sustainability, community value, and improved public realms. The critical aspects of this study include mixed-use development promotion for creating live communities, public and green spaces expansion for liveable environments, and movement improvement through pedestrian-oriented design and improved transit links (Arnstein, 2019). Such rules are designed to ensure that the development will positively affect the area’s social, economic, and environmental character from an equity-focused urban development perspective. Reviewing the proposed development on 1910 Eglinton Ave E about the Golden Mile Secondary Plan standards will indicate a tremendous urban fairness potential. The proposal for a mixed-use development approach aligns with the objectives of the plan to develop urban spaces that are linked and animated, and that would be suitable for a diverse range of communities. Figure 1: Google Street View of the present location at 1910 Eglinton Ave E right247144700right000Source: google map view Critical Analysis Equity planning is crucial in urban development to meet the demands of such residents. A 1910 Eglinton Ave E development application is examined for equity planning and Golden Mile Secondary Plan compliance. It is done by studying the parties that will be advantaged by the intended kind of development and those that will stand to lose. The public consultation strategy is evaluated through Arnstein’s (2019) citizen participation ladder. A section on transportation equity is also added to evaluate the particular effects of the development application. Equity Planning Lens Application The main concern of equity planning is creating equitable communities whereby all residents, especially the marginalized and vulnerable, have access to resources, services, and opportunities. It emphasizes equity in resource distribution and participatory planning. This approach concerns the results that may satisfy everybody in society, including those often left out in traditional planning (Gaber, 2019). Equity planning involves examining how the 1910 Eglinton Ave E project meets principles of equitable benefits to all community members, especially the most vulnerable or disadvantaged. This evaluation considers the project’s focus on inclusiveness and the fair distribution of its benefits among different segments of society. Equity planning is designed to reallocate resources, access to opportunities, and services to those who need them the most, inclusive involvement in planning processes, and results in solving social inequities. The proposed development at 1910 Eglinton Ave E could benefit the local neighborhood by providing more homes and diversified space uses with mixed-use structures (Sandercock, 1998). Nevertheless, the effect on different classes, mainly the disadvantaged groups, is determined by several variables such as affordability, accessibility, and comprehensiveness of facilities and services. Newcomers who have the opportunity to live in modern housing and a lively community space anticipate being the beneficiaries of the development. The development will introduce increased foot traffic and the economic vitality that the local businesses may exploit (Pendall, 2000). However, the condition of its existing residents who suffer increased rent and living costs could lead to a replacement of lower-income families and individuals. The gentrification phenomenon that usually follows urban renewal projects could weaken communities. For the development to fully conform to equity planning principles, measures must be included to minimize these risks (Fischler, 2012). To promote fairness and equality, the project pledges to allocate a substantial proportion of affordable homes and guarantee that amenities and facilities are readily available to persons of all price brackets. Furthermore, this approach actively engages community people in planning to address and integrate their distinct needs and concerns directly. Public Consultation Strategy Analysis The 1910 Eglinton Ave East development public consultation process assessment using Arnstein’s Ladder of Citizen Participation concentrates on measuring citizen empowerment beyond merely imparting information. Arnstein’s typology defines eight levels of citizen participation, from non-participation through several forms of tokenism to citizen control (Arnstein, 2019). This model is a roadmap to the transition from engagement to real empowerment in decision-making processes. In a genuinely enabling public consultation process, an individual would be looking for strategies that partner the citizens with the government and allow them to produce ideas that would be factored into the final decisions. This would fall under the higher levels of Arnstein’s ladder, namely “partnershi...