Representational Model Versus the Aesthetic Regime
Case 1: the representational model versus the aesthetic regime
In class we have discussed the contrast between the 'representational model' of art and what has been called 'aesthetic regime of art', particularly emphasizing the very different way in which, from both, the ethical-political meaning of practices is understood. artistic. Reflect on this contrast, making explicit the points of difference, the implications of these differences, and the questions that may also remain open. To carry out this reflection, use examples: you can choose the same work or artistic practice that can be interpreted from the two models; or you can choose two works and the opinion of their creators about them to contrast the two models; or you can, finally, take into account what a couple of art critics or thinkers about art say in relation to it, to reflect on the contrast and its implications. To elaborate on these implications and the questions that may arise, take into account how in both cases we think about what art does and the way in which it can have an ethical-political effect. Please use information from these books.
The Representational Model Versus The Aesthetic Regime
Student's Name
University, Department
Professor's Name
Course Number
Date
The representational model of art is based on the idea that art is a form of imitation or representation of reality, a principle also echoed in Plato’s Mimesis, and that its value and meaning depend on how well it conforms to specific rules, norms, and criteria of accuracy, beauty, and morality. According to this model, art has a fixed function: instruct, delight, or persuade the viewers and reflect the values and ideals of a given society, culture, or religion (Judith, 2021). Art is also seen as a separate and distinct domain from other forms of human activity, such as politics, science, or religion, and as a privileged source of knowledge, pleasure, and virtue. Knoos et al. (2023) indicate that the iconicity of representational art may give viewers an easy and high-level understanding. It coerces subjectivity from the viewer even without additional information.
The aesthetic regime of art is based on the idea that art is a form of expression or creation of sensible forms and that its value and meaning depend on how it challenges, transforms, or subverts the existing norms, categories, and hierarchies of perception, understanding, and judgment. Forged by Jacques Rancière, this regime purports that art has no predefined or fixed function but rather the potential to invent new ways of seeing, feeling, and thinking and to question the established order of things (Tanke, 2011). From the aesthetic perspective, modern art engages in self-purification processes through which art rids itself of elements borrowed from other