Journal review. Summary of Authors’ Arguments. Coursework
INTRODUCTION TO NGO MANAGEMENT, 2019 - 2020
CW1 – Journal article critical reading (1000 words)
STUDENT NUMBER: ________________
ARTICLE: Kraft, Kathryn and Jonathan Smith. 2018. “Between international
donors and local faith communities: Intermediaries in humanitarian
assistance to Syrian refugees in Jordan and Lebanon.” Disasters,
2019, 43(1): 24−45.
Guidelines:
● Find the article via the online library journal databases.
● Read the article carefully and take notes of the key points throughout.
● Answer all five questions below on this sheet, writing in full grammatical
sentences. Each answer can be the length you think necessary, for a total of
approx. 1000 words.
● In your answers to numbers 2-4, include the page numbers on which you
found the information to which you are responding/referring
● Review and proof read your work to ensure it is clear and accurate.
● Submit your work to the Turn it In Link on the Moodle site for SY4007 by 4pm
Wednesday 26 February 2020 at the latest. It can, of course, be earlier…
………………………………………………………………………………………………..
1. In your own words summarise what you believe to be the authors’ main
argument.
2. What kinds of evidence do the authors use to support their arguments?
3. What are 4 different types of NGO to which the article refers? Offer your own
definition of each type based on the description and analysis in the article.
4. In your view, what are the limitations of the article?
5. Which of the references cited in the article will you follow up and why?
JOURNAL REVIEW
by Student’s Name
Course
Professor
University
City, State
Date
JOURNAL REVIEW
Summary of Authors’ Arguments
The authors note that the war in Syria has led to a crisis not only in providing relief to the thousands of men, women, and children fleeing their homes, but also in issues of accountability. In the wake of the problems war creates such as homelessness, the need for food, drugs, and shelter, many humanitarian organizations have sprung up. While they are doing a commendable job and helping to absorb the refugees in various camps, logistical issues arise such as language barriers, cultural conflicts, and the need to explain how billions of shillings are used. To help resolve the crises, two Christian intermediary groups help to connect locals with donors, complete the paperwork, identify needy groups, and provide aid neutrally and impartially. Therefore, the authors’ central argument is that there is a need for intermediaries between the NGOs and local support groups to bridge the gaps mentioned above.
Evidence
The authors rely on case studies from two Christian intermediary groups as they arbitrated between international groups and the local faith and church-based organizations in Lebanon and Jordan. Often, they noted that without the interventions, there were problems such as donor pressure, aid restrictions, and general misunderstandings. However, when the groups intervened, they were able to resolve the issues holistically (Kraft & Smith 2019, pp.28-30). Sometimes, the donors could not effectively communicate with those in charge. Given the massive amounts of money involved, the intermediaries facilitated the hiring of accountants, interpreters, and helped to make the process seamless and localized. In other words, they want to see the people they know delivering the services, which is what the groups do to make them comfortable. To facilitate the process, the donors use the locals who already know the people. They are more confident in the local groups because they can mobile funds and ensure people at the grassroots get the aid they need.
Four types of NGO
The article refers to four main NGO types. They are private and governmental donors, international humanitarians, national governments, and local organizations (Kraft & Smith 2019, p.25). Private donors comprise individuals who use their money to help finance humanitarian services to citizens in need. They could be wealthy or philanthropic businesspersons who have the heart to help needy people, such as the refugees in Syria. International humanitarian agencies are the most common form o...
👀 Other Visitors are Viewing These APA Essay Samples:
-
Gender Roles as Men and Women Are Fundamentally Different Coursework
2 pages/≈550 words | No Sources | Harvard | Social Sciences | Coursework |
-
Do globalising processes give advantages to developing countries?
3 pages/≈825 words | No Sources | Harvard | Social Sciences | Coursework |
-
Economic Inequality, Political Inequality, and Political Polarization
8 pages/≈2200 words | No Sources | Harvard | Social Sciences | Coursework |