Evidentialism, Genuine Option, and General Epistemic Principle
1. In “The Ethics of Belief,” Clifford argues for a view called Evidentialism. What is Evidentialism? Limit your answer to one sentence. (2 points)
2. Explain one potential objection to Evidentialism. No more than four sentences. (3 points)
3. In “The Will to Believe,” William James introduces the notion of a “genuine option.” What does James mean by a ‘genuine option’? (3 points)
4. James claims that religious belief is a genuine option. Why? No more than five sentences. (5 points)
5. Consider the following case: Jones and Smith are both applying for the same job, and Smith has ten coins in his pocket; Jones is justified in believing that Smith will get the job and that he has ten coins in his pocket; Jones infers that ‘the man who will get the job has ten coins in his pocket.’ According to Gettier, Jones is justified in believing that ‘the man who will get the job has ten coins in his pocket.’ Why? No more than two sentences. (3 points)
6. Consider the following definition of knowledge: S knows that P if and only if (a) S believes P, (b) P is true, (c) S is justified in believing P, and (d) S does not infer P from a false premise. Construct a case which shows that this definition does not provide sufficient conditions for knowledge. No more than five sentences. (5 points)
7. An argument for external world skepticism will take the form of just two premises and a conclusion. The first premise might look something like this:
1) If you know that coffee contains caffeine, then you can know that the evil demon hypothesis is false.
Complete the argument. (2 points)
8. What general epistemic principle is premise (1) from above an instance of? One sentence. (2 points)
Philosophy Exercise
Name
Institution
Philosophy Exercise
Question One
Evidentialism is taken to mean whatever it takes for a person to believe reasonably, or justifiably, in a proposition that is thought to be needed for knowledge.
Question Two
One objection to evidentialism arises from the tendency of people to forget the evidence they might have had for a proposition. The argument here is that even though a person had good evidence for believing a proposition, they have forgotten it. Therefore, a person can continue believing justifiably without any supporting evidence.
Question Three
James uses genuine option to refer to an option that is momentous, forced, and simultaneously living. By momentous, James holds that the option may matter to us depending on the hypothesis we adopt ad different times. By forced, he means that the option leaves people with no other place to stand outside of it. Finally, he means that the option may be living for us especially if our stance on moral truths gives us things we can possibly believe in.
Question Four
James argues that religious beliefs instill in people a notion that they will be better off if they believe that the eternal things are the best things. To James, there ...
👀 Other Visitors are Viewing These APA Essay Samples:
-
Aristotle's Theory, Qualities by Locke, Berkeley Principles, and Leibniz Conclusion
2 pages/≈550 words | 3 Sources | APA | Social Sciences | Coursework |
-
Organizational Behavior Solution’s Connection With OB Research
2 pages/≈550 words | 1 Source | APA | Social Sciences | Coursework |
-
A Bill to Close Chinese Factories Where Workers Are Treated Inhumanely
1 page/≈275 words | 4 Sources | APA | Social Sciences | Coursework |